Some parts of a vehicle get all the attention. Drivers know oil changes and tire rotations are important to the safety and longevity of a vehicle, so they diligently perform the necessary services themselves or take their car or truck to a trusted mechanic.
Other components like transmissions often get neglected. Drivers aren’t sure what manual and automatic transmissions need to operate properly and, so services are sometimes missed. In the worst cases, that can translate to a costly transmission failure.
To take the mystery out of transmission service, we called Steve Heggie at Certified Transmission and Auto Service in Crestwood, Kentucky. A NAPA AutoCare Center serving the Louisville area, his shop sees its fair share of customers in need of transmission service or repairs. We asked Heggie to provide his insights on how to maintain your transmission, and what happens when a gearbox fails.
What’s the difference between a manual transmission and an automatic?
Because manual and automatic transmissions use different methods to transfer engine power to the drive wheels, comparing the two, according to Heggie, is “night and day.” Both use transmission fluid to lubricate and cool internal parts, but automatic transmissions also depend on the fluid to transmit power hydraulically, exposing the fluid to far more heat than in a standard-shift transmission. That’s why clean fluid is especially important in automatics.
How often does an automatic transmission need service?
Heggie explained that all transmissions are different, and that drivers should familiarize themselves with their model’s specific requirements. Some recommend a service interval of 20,000 miles for transmission flush and filter change. Others may recommend service as infrequently as every 50,000 miles. Check your owner’s manual for recommended transmission service intervals.
Do some driving conditions cause more transmission wear than others?
Heggie recommends that drivers are careful not to overload vehicles or trailers, especially in warm weather and on long trips. Overheating a transmission can lead to failure.
“When you see a car on the side of the road, nine out of ten times it’s a heat related issue,” Heggie said. “It could be a cooling system failure or a transmission failure, but chances are it’s caused by excessive heat.”
Mud or snow can cause problems, too. Heggie says that when a driver switches back and forth quickly between “drive” and “reverse,” such as to free the vehicle from mud or snow, heat builds in its automatic transmission. He recommends drivers never use this method.
What are some signs of a weak or failing automatic transmission?
Heggie provided an adage about transmission failures: “summer heat causes winter problems.” In other words, damage done during warmer months may not reveal itself until the weather turns cold. Hundreds of expanding and contracting O-rings may begin to leak in winter months. This could result in a lack of power, delayed shifts or slipping. An electrical issue with an automatic transmission often results in a “check engine” light on the dash or, in some Ford models, a flashing “overdrive” light.
An issue with a manual transmission may show different symptoms like grinding noise during gear shifts or difficulty changing gears. Both automatic and manual transmissions may slip, through. In a stick-shift vehicle, slippage may be a sign of a worn clutch. When replacing a clutch, don’t forget to replace the engine’s rear main seal at the same time.
Are these symptoms a sure sign of failing transmission?
Not necessarily. In fact, Heggie said that some issues that appear to be related to a vehicle’s transmission are often caused by another component.
“I’d say seven or eight out of ten cars that come in for transmission repair don’t have a transmission problem,” Heggie said. “A bad spark plug or clogged catalytic converter can cause similar symptoms, so a proper diagnosis is very important.”
What’s the most important thing drivers can do at home to ensure a long-lasting transmission?
Heggie says drivers should exercise patience with their vehicles, check transmission fluid regularly and stick to a maintenance schedule.
For an automatic transmission, allow the transmission to fully engage before accelerating. Read your owner’s manual or look online to find out how to check fluid in your model. Some vehicles require that the vehicle be running. Some suggest the vehicle should be in “park,” while others should use “neutral.” Finally, learn what service intervals your vehicle’s manufacturer recommends, and follow the schedule closely.
Did you find this article helpful? Have a question about your vehicle’s transmission? Let us know in the comments below.
Certified Transmission & Auto Service
6540 West Highway 146
Crestwood, Kentucky 40014
Nick Palermo is a freelance automotive writer and NAPA Know How blogger. Since becoming an auto news and reviews contributor at AutoTrader.com in 2011, he has broadened his coverage of the automotive industry to include topics like new car technology, antiques and classics, DIY maintenance and repair, industry news and motorsports. A committed advocate for automotive media professionals, Nick is a member of the Greater Atlanta Automotive Media Association.